The MINESCAPES Working Group brings together scholars across disciplines, regions, and historical periods to explore the histories and afterlives of mining and extraction. Focusing on the material, epistemic, and ecological dimensions of mining, the group provides a forum for works-in-progress, methodological exchange, and collaborative engagement. Spanning a range of disciplinary approaches, the group centers mining as a complex site of labor, knowledge production, and environmental transformation. This group is open to all and meets monthly during the academic year to discuss pre-circulated papers.

Upcoming Meetings

Monday, December 14, 2026, 1:00 - 2:30 pm EST

Preindustrial mining in highland southwest China and Southeast Asia: A field-based approach

Nanny Kim (University of Cologne)

Abstract: Chinese mining history faces an extreme scarcity of records. In the way of introducing the background, this talk briefly outlines worldviews and textual traditions that shape historic representations. The main part presents an approach that combines historic, historico-geographical, and anthropo-historical methodologies in locating sites, researching materials, and short-term fieldwork. It uses two case studies of silver mines to discusses work on past and present minescapes.

Bio: Nanny Kim is a China historian interested in everyday life. She mainly works on mining and transport networks in the mountain zone of southwest China and northern Southeast Asia during the early modern period. Since 2015, she has worked on field-based research that mainly focusses on silver mines in Yunnan with funding by three 3-year projects by the German Research Foundation (DFG) and a membership with the IAS, Princeton.

Monday, January 11, 2027, 1:00 - 2:30 pm EST

TBA

Monday, February 8, 2027, 1:00 - 2:30 pm EST

Annelise Walker (Penn State University), “Opals Are Found in Inca Tombs”: Collecting Minerals without Mines or Miners, Alto Perú, 1753–1784

Abstract: “‘Opals Are Found in Inca Tombs’: Collecting without Mines or Miners” is the third chapter of “Collecting the Subterranean: Mining and Minerals in Eighteenth-Century Alto Perú and Spain,” a dissertation that reconstructs the networks Spain used to fill its Royal Cabinet of Natural History with minerals from Alto Perú (modern-day Bolivia), the center of the empire’s mining industry. It traces the institution’s transition, over the course of the eighteenth century, from using the Spanish imperial bureaucracy to collect specimens to funding a dedicated mineralogical expedition to Alto Perú, emphasizing the enduring centrality of Indigenous miners to the collecting process throughout this change. This chapter uses correspondence and shipment catalogs written to accompany natural curiosities in their journey across the Atlantic to explore the barriers to mineral collecting that mounted in Alto Perú in the second half of the eighteenth century. These included labor shortages due to the depopulation of Indigenous communities; flooding and high maintenance costs; and the exhaustion of mines that had been worked, by then, for centuries—revealing that the region’s mining industry caused the very issues which threatened it. By linking Spanish mineral collecting to mining, I argue that mineral collecting both benefitted from and slowed due to the social and environmental violence wrought by colonial mining. Finally, this chapter explores the ways collectors responded to the Crown’s orders when they had no minerals to send, turning eventually to the mineral collections of prehispanic peoples (“in Inca tombs”).

Bio: Annelise Walker is a 5th-year PhD candidate in the Department of History at Penn State and a 2026–27 research fellow at the John Carter Brown Library and the Linda Hall Science Library. Their dissertation, “Collecting the Subterranean: Mining and Minerals in Eighteenth-Century Alto Perú and Spain,” reconstructs the social and material networks the Spanish Royal Cabinet of Natural History used to collect mineral specimens from Alto Perú (Bolivia), highlighting the intellectual contributions of Indigenous men and women laboring in the silver industry. Their research interests include the history of science, Indigenous knowledge, material culture, and the subterranean.

Monday, March 8, 2027, 1:00 - 2:30 pm EST

Oksana G. Tsay (Kh.M. Abdullayev Institute of Geology and Geophysics), "From Punch Card to Predictor: Making the Catalogue of Faults of the Middle and Southern Tien Shan, 1980s-2026" 

Abstract: This paper follows one regional dataset through four media - card file, printed catalogue, relational database and table of coded attributes - and asks what each transfer standardised, preserved and left behind.

The catalogue began as the personal card file of Lora N. Lordkipanidze (1932-2022), a historian of the geology of Uzbekistan, kept for three decades on punched cards, the ordinary stationery of Soviet institutes. In 2015 the file was digitised as 120 scans of about 163 cards; the originals were returned to their author and one card is lost. The 2016 printed edition fixed 806 status definitions - deep fault, lineament, suture, flexure-fracture zone - for literature of 1903 to 2015, in a list approved by a single scholar. Publication did not close the corpus: a systematic search for the eighteen fields of each record produced objects that were not on the list, and the database now holds 3,575 records from about 690 sources, resolving into 1,059 numbered faults and 1,139 name variants.

Two problems organise the paper. The first is identity: the same structure bears different names in different authors' schemes, answered on the cards by synonymy and in the database by a fixed list of permanent numbers. The second is authorship: the author of a source is a field of the database, and scans of the original schemes are attached to the records. The final transfer turns descriptions into fourteen coded predictors over 1,549 validated fault segments. The paper does not claim that coding removes bias; it shows where the categories came from, who authorised them, and what stayed outside.

Bio: Oksana G. Tsay is a junior researcher at the Kh.M. Abdullayev Institute of Geology and Geophysics in Tashkent, Uzbekistan, with thirty-five years of work in structural geology, hydrogeology and GIS-based spatial analysis. Since 2015 she has built and maintained the Catalogue of Faults of the Middle and Southern Tien Shan and adjacent areas, which began as the punch-card file of her supervisor Lora N. Lordkipanidze (1932-2022) and is now a relational database of 3,575 records drawn from about 690 sources published between 1903 and 2017. A member of INHIGEO since 2019, she co-authors the annual Uzbekistan report for the INHIGEO Annual Record and has published a biographical study of Lordkipanidze as a historian of geology (Geological Society, London, Special Publications 564, 2026).

Monday, April 12, 2027, 1:00 - 2:30 pm EDT

TBA

Monday, May 10, 2027, 1:00 - 2:30 pm EDT

TBA

Past Meetings

-

Title: Using STS Theories to Bridge HST and Art History: Or, How to Talk About Public Monuments with Too Many Acronyms

Allison Bigelow (Notre Dame)

Abstract: On November 3, 1921, a cheering crowd of white citizens in and around Charlottesville, Virginia, gathered to dedicate the city’s newest statue: a 24-foot-tall equestrian monument of revolutionary war general George Rogers Clark (1752-1818), depicted as he charged into an unarmed crowd of Native men, women, and children. Since the earliest days of the US republic, when crowds tore down a statue of George III on July 6, 1776, in lower Manhattan, to the removal, renaming, and defending of Confederate monuments in our own time, citizens and leaders have debated the meaning of monuments in public life. These debates have often turned upon ideas of race, citizenship, and history, and they have generally fallen into two camps: those who see statues as history that can't be erased, and those who see statues as symbols designed to project a specific vision of the past (and, therefore, a topic that might do well to take a backseat to more pressing issues like human rights legislation, food insecurity, and affordable housing) (Savage 1997, Thompson 2021, Cox and Domby, eds., 2023, Hooker 2024). Despite years of research by historians and art historians, public debates about monuments have not changed much in the past 30 years. For their parts, HST scholars who have studied novel forms of copper metallurgy and the expansion of industrial mining in the 1910s-1920s have not tended to connect these new technologies and mechanized modes of extraction to changes in statuary. As an effort to reframe public conversations about statues, this talk borrows a lifecycle approach from STS (Geiser 2015, Mah 2023), to show how tracing metals and stones in public art back to their cultural and geographic origins offers a new framework and vocabulary for policy debates. Rather than seeing statues only as part of local landscapes, we begin to see them as products and processes of global chains of extraction, metallurgical processing, and industrial capitalism. This talk comes from chapter two of a book project that I am co-authoring with Teresa Pollak (Monacan), Beverly Payne (Occaneechi-Saponi), and Shaleigh Howells (settler, former cultural resources officer of the Pamunkey Nation), about our committee's work to remove the George Rogers Clark statue from the campus of the University of Virginia in 2021.
 

Bio:

Allison Bigelow is an associate professor in the Department of Romance Languages at the University of Notre Dame, where she teaches classes on the history of science and technology in Latin America, public monuments and historical memory, and community-engaged research methods. She is the author of 30-ish articles and chapters on those topics, as well as Mining Language: Racial Thinking, Indigenous Knowledge, and the Early Modern Iberian World (Omohundro Institute of Early American History and Culture/UNC Press, 2020), which received awards from HSS (Pauly Prize for First Book on the Americas), AHA (Rawley Prize for Atlantic History), MLA (First Book) and CLAH (Cline Prize for Latin American Ethnohistory, honorable mention). Her current book project, co-authored with Tribal consultants, traces the lifecycle of the University of Virginia's monument to George Rogers Clark, which stood on the campus from 1921 to 2021.

-

Amelia Hutchinson (Deutsches Bergbau-Museum Bochum)

From Archive to Outcrop: Living with Risk in the Mining Towns of Habsburg Hungary, c.1550-1750

In 1615, the French physician Jean Baptiste Morin toured the mining towns of the Kingdom of Hungary, among early modern Europe's richest sites of copper, silver, and gold. Entering a mine by 'crawling upon all fours, with a great deal of pain', Morin described miners emerging from the shaft 'with faces more like dead than living men'. This paper examines how inhabitants of Hungarian mining towns (present-day Slovakia) confronted danger through the interconnected relationship between religion, materiality, and the environment, exploring their bodily and devotional practices, and the volatile landscapes reshaped by shafts, smelters, and flood-prone waterways. Drawing on travel reports, mining ordinances, and visual and material sources, I argue that managing risk was an embodied and everyday practice. Sitting at the confluence of empire, confession, and commodity production, these towns formed a military and commodity frontier subject to imperial ordinances that attempted to regulate safety and orthodoxy alike. Yet, it was in the shafts, fraternities, and fields that such norms were tested and adapted. This paper brings the archival record into dialogue with visits to former mining sites, where copper verdigris marking slag heaps and waterways, the dense patchwork of churches, and the sulphuric soil remain legible traces of these same negotiations. Moving between these different archives, the paper explores how landscape can complicate and complement the written record, offering a fuller account of how communities on an early modern extractive frontier made instability liveable.

-

Deep Space Extractivism: The Negative Portrayal of Mining in Hollywood’s Science Fiction by Brian Leech (Augustana College)

Abstract: Historian Sally Zanjani once argued that “mining has a worse image in the movies than the mafia.” Later research has confirmed her impression, even if the image varies based on the landscape setting and the materials being mined. Westerns about precious metals tend to focus on frontier greed and social isolation, for instance, while coal movies emphasize class conflict, company power, and disaster. This book chapter will argue that these pre-existing negative tropes have been exaggerated in post-1970s science fiction films such as Outland (1981), Total Recall (1990), Moon (2009), The Hunger Games (2012), and Prospect (2018). Setting the action in the extreme environments of distant planets allows American filmmakers to critique the mining industry’s past, present, and future. 

Biography: Brian Leech is Associate Professor and Chair of History at Augustana College in Rock Island, Illinois, where he also serves as Director of the Knowlton Honors Program. An environmental historian, most of his research focuses on natural resource industries, including his 2018 book The City That Ate Itself: Butte, Montana and Its Expanding Berkeley Pit. He recently became as fascinated by fake mines as real ones. This presentation comes from his book project on the portrayal of mining in American popular culture. 

-

Community Care and Environmental Health in the Early Extractocene by Guy Geltner (Monash University)

In this seminar Guy Geltner will discuss his ongoing work on premodern miners’ health and their related understanding of the environment, both below and above the ground. We will also touch upon the long term and often invisible legacies of manual extraction, how it continues to impact public health today, and why examining both benefit from an interdisciplinary approach. See linked video: Argentaria: Sardinia's Lost Silver Mines. 

-

New Methods in Mining Studies II

Environmental Lifeworlds of Extraction in Africa: Methodological Insights by Iva Peša (University of Groningen)

The AFREXTRACT project studies the environmental histories of mining and oil drilling in Johannesburg, the Zambian Copperbelt, and the Niger Delta from 1950 onwards. We are particularly interested in understanding lived experiences of environmental transformation. In this presentation, we would like to share our methodology - a mix of archival research, oral histories, ethnography, literary and musical analysis, and photography. This approach is geared towards documenting 'environmental lifeworlds', a concept that highlights processes of living with pollution and toxicity in everyday life. 

Mining Central European Archives: Some Notes on Method by Sebastian Felten, Claire Sabel, and Sebastian Leitner (University of Vienna)

The SCARCE project investigates historical dimensions of resource management. We examine early modern Central Europe, a region where centuries of mining have left behind a rich cultural heritage and marks of environmental degradation. This presentation will showcase work-in-progress from some of our case studies (Saxon Ore Mountains, Idrija/Venice, Habsburg Hungary) and center on problems of method: accessing archival records through dispersed multilingual metadata; integrating diverse perspectives (financial, medical, geological, environmental) into Central European "minescapes"; and searching for a non-reductionist framework of global connection and comparison.

-

Deren Ertas (Harvard University) 

"From the Mine to the Market: A History of Silver in the Eighteenth-Century Ottoman Empire"

Abstract: This presentation traces the journey of silver from its extraction at the Keban Mine in Eastern Anatolia to its transformation into coinage at the Ottoman Imperial Mint in Istanbul during the long eighteenth century (c. 1692–1830). Using archival fragments and a “possible history” approach, I reconstruct the technical, social, and administrative processes of Ottoman silver production. The narrative follows the establishment and operation of the Keban Mine, the organization of labor, infrastructure, and capital, the transport of silver across Anatolia, and its final purification and coinage at the Imperial Mint. By examining these processes, the study highlights how the Ottoman state gradually increased its control over mining revenues—a trend that contrasts with contemporary patterns of agrarian privatization. Tracing silver from ore to coin reveals the economic, social, and administrative complexities of the Ottoman mining sector and money production in the eighteenth century.

-

Anna Graber (University of Minnesota), Making Mineralogy Russian: Bashkirs, Mining Administrators, and Earth Knowledges of the Urals, 1700-1819

As administrators of the Russian state mining system sought to regularize and expand metallurgical production in the Urals in the 1720s, they were obliged to rely on the labor and skill of a diverse population of miners and metal workers who, while lacking a scientific approach to minerals, nevertheless brought to the industry their own earth knowledges. This paper, a chapter of my book manuscript-in-progress “Tsardom of Rock: Knowing the Earth in Russia’s Mining Empire," examines the local knowledge of Bashkir ore finders, the chief body of prospectors in the Southern Urals and the Orenburg Steppe, and mine administrators’ evaluation of this knowledge. Initially highly esteemed by mining administrators, Bashkir mining knowledge was cast aside as Bashkirs’ political power waned in successive failed rebellions in favor of universalized, academic mineralogy. Still, the local focus of Bashkir mineral knowledge—as well as the local and experimental nature of copper metallurgy—provoked mine administrators and mine owners to develop a sense of regional and national specificity in their adaptation of mining science coming from Germany and Sweden. This concept of a national Russian mineralogy in turn helped construct the Russian Empire as a geologically coherent whole, naturalizing borders and imperial rule in frontier areas that began encountering direct rule from St. Petersburg only in the eighteenth century. Mining elites’ answer to epistemic diversity was to develop some of the first nationalist rhetoric in Russian science and to discursively define Russia from the ground up. 

-

Presenter: Laith Shakir (New York University) 

Title: "Aeriel Photography, Oil, and Archaeology in the Interwar Middle East"

Abstract: In the period between the two world wars, the post-Ottoman Middle East witnessed a measurable increase in two forms of subterranean engagement: archeological excavation and petroleum exploration. Historians of each field science have tended to study them in isolation from one another. However, using the archives of the Anglo-Persian Oil Company (APOC) and the Iraq Petroleum Company (IPC), I argue that the histories of these two field sciences are intimately linked. This paper examines how oil companies embraced aerial surveying—a novel technique refined during World War I and later adopted by archaeologists and geologists alike—across their operations in the Middle East. Using aerial photography, the APOC and IPC surveyed the region’s landscape to chart out routes for railways, roads, and pipelines and to identify potential sites for oil extraction. By focusing on the IPC’s support of two archaeological expeditions—the 1937 Wakefield Expedition to the Hadhramaut and Aurel Stein’s 1938-9 aerial surveys of the Roman limes in Iraq and Transjordan—I show how the field sciences of petroleum geology and archaeology were entangled with one another and with the British Empire’s political and economic designs for the region more broadly. Though seemingly counterintuitive, these entanglements also reveal how scientists took to the air to better understand the subterranean world decades before the widespread embrace of satellite imagery and other, more familiar, remote sensing techniques. 

 

 

-

New Approaches in Mining Studies

Timothy James LeCain (Montana): Do Coal and Oil Drive History? The New Materialism and the Question of Mineral Agency

In recent years, as the new materialism, more-than-human history, and other theoretical and methodological innovations have gained influence, scholars have begun to rethink the potential agency of minerals. Conventional anthropocentric histories have generally viewed minerals as largely passive objects that human beings extract, process, and use. More recent scholarship, however, has suggested that we must consider that minerals have certain material natures and potentials—what James Gibson termed “affordances”—that exercise significant influences over how humans feel, think, and act. This potentiality has become a matter of especial concern regarding the two most significant climate-warming minerals, coal and oil. Dipesh Chakrabarty famously, and controversially, asserted in 2009 that, “The mansions of modern freedom stand on an ever-expanding base of fossil fuel use.” Other scholars have probed the nature of carbon itself—the element that gives coal and oil their energetic potential—suggesting that humans have been lured and trapped into close relationship with these minerals that they cannot easily escape. Others disagree, arguing that such readings are mistakenly deterministic and thus neglect the true anthropocentric causes of global warming, such as colonialism or capitalism. In this talk, I argue that these debates over mineral agency and determinism are really debates about whether human cognition and culture exist primarily in our brains, or whether they extend out into the world around us. I conclude that the second may be the more convincing stance, and if so, there is a strong case that coal and oil should stand alongside of humans as central drivers of history.

-

Collaborative Research on Mining I: Roundtable with Pamela Smith & Daviken Studnicki-Gizbert 

Daviken Studnicki-Gizbert (McGill University): Historical research within the field of contemporary extractivist politics: observations from collaborations in Mexico, Panama, and Québec.  

This presentation focuses on the political dimensions of collaborative research in the history of mining, and extractivism more broadly. For people and territories facing the incursions of mining, hydroelectric, or logging projects, contemporary extractivism generates intense fields of political debate and action. What are the possible contributions of university-based historical research to these fields? Conversely, how can the collaborative mode reconfigure the agendas, methods, and creations of conventional research? Three projects undertaken with social movements and Indigenous communities in Mexico, Panama, and Québec offer some observations on the practice, challenges, and possibilities of this mode of research.

Dimitrios Mitsopoulos (Columbia University) & Jennifer Amaya (Columbia Climate School): Remains in the Minescape: Education about Lead in Lavrion, Greece

This collaborative project aims to increase public awareness of lead contamination in Lavrion, Greece, where the cumulative effects of 5000+ years of silver mining have been mapped by geo-chemists and are known in some detail, however public knowledge of the high levels of lead pollution has lagged behind. The project includes an environmental chemist, a historian, doctoral students in history and geochemistry and teachers of history and chemistry at a local secondary school. The teachers and grad students are preparing lesson plans about the local history which will be combined with soil testing for lead with a portable kit. The student testing, which will be carried out in Spring 2026, builds on previous projects in Peru and Germany.

-

Welcome to the Minescapes Working Group!  

Welcome and Introduction by Conveners

Presentations: 

  • Tina Asmussen (Ruhr University Bochum / German Mining Museum) and Pamela H. Smith (Columbia University): Minescapes: Socio-natural Landscapes of Extraction and Knowledge

    This presentation introduces the MINESCAPES project, which investigates mining landscapes as socio-natural sites shaped by centuries of human-environment interaction. Through interdisciplinary collaboration between natural sciences and humanities, the project examines the "archives of nature and culture"—from soils, water, and vegetation to historical maps, manuscripts, and material objects. Integrating material landscape analysis, scientific methods, and archival research in a longue durée perspective, MINESCAPES illuminates how extractive practices have fundamentally reconfigured ecosystems and societies across millennia. By transcending established nature-culture dichotomies, this methodology yields historical insights critical for understanding contemporary debates on resource extraction, sustainability, and climate change. 

  • Deren Ertas and Jordan Howell: Brief explanation of the Call for Papers

Question & Answer

Group Conveners

Tina Asmussen

Tina Asmussen (PhD, University of Lucerne) is Professor in the History Department at Ruhr University Bochum and Head of the Mining History Research Section at the German Mining Museum in Bochum. Before joining Bochum, she served as Assistant Professor at the Chair of Science Studies at ETH Zurich (2017–20) and was a Postdoctoral Research Fellow at the Max Planck Institute for the History of Science in Berlin (2014–17). Her first book, Scientia Kircheriana: Die Fabrikation des Wissens bei Athanasius Kircher (Didymos-Verlag, 2016), examined how Kircherian knowledge was produced, circulated, and legitimized through scholarly, patronage, and Jesuit networks, highlighting the interplay between scholarly practices, material culture, and institutional contexts. Her current research focuses on the history of early modern mining and georesources, approached as an environmental and economic history of knowledge.

 

Deren Ertas

Deren Ertas is a Postdoctoral Research Associate in International and Public Affairs at the Watson School and Department of History at Brown University. She recently defended her dissertation entitled "The Imperial Minescape: Labor, Nature, and the Pursuit of 'Cheap' Metal in the Eighteenth-Century Ottoman Empire" in History and Middle Eastern Studies at Harvard University. Her work has been published in Radical Philosophy, Jadaliyya, Arab Studies Journal, and Political Concepts: A Critical Lexicon.

 

Jordan Howell

Jordan Howell is a historian of the United States and the world, with a focus on corporations, empire, and labor. He's currently finishing his first book, Imperial Crucible: Building and Battling the Aluminum Company of America, 1888-1962, under contract with Columbia University Press. His dissertation on Alcoa was a finalist for the Krooss and Nevins prizes. His writing on bauxite mining has appeared in Environmental History and a summary of his dissertation can be found in Enterprise & Society. His next project is a global history of American multinationals, beginning with the Pacific Mail Steamship Company, founded in 1848.

 

Pamela Smith

Pamela H. Smith, Seth Low Professor of History at Columbia University, is founding Director of the Center for Science and Society and its cluster project the Making and Knowing Project (www.makingandknowing.org). Her books, including The Business of Alchemy (1994), The Body of the Artisan (2004), and From Lived Experience to the Written Word: Reconstructing Practical Knowledge in the Early Modern World (2022), investigate craft and practice as a way of knowing. She has collaborated on edited volumes that treat the history of practice, embodied knowledge, and material culture. She led the Making and Knowing Project’s multiyear creation of Secrets of Craft and Nature in Renaissance France (2020) and its open access research and teaching resources, the Research and Teaching Companion for instructors and students wishing to integrate hands-on lessons into teaching and learning, and an open source and customizable publishing tool, EditionCrafter, which allows users to publish digital editions as feature-rich and sustainable static sites. She is now working on longue durée histories of socio-natural sites of pre-industrial industry.

 

170 Members

You must be a member to view resources. Login or create an account
Image
Heniochus chrysostomus

Heniochus chrysostomus, Julius bifer, from The Zoology of Captain Beechey’s Voyage, 1839.