Title: Using STS Theories to Bridge HST and Art History: Or, How to Talk About Public Monuments with Too Many Acronyms
Allison Bigelow (Notre Dame)
Abstract: On November 3, 1921, a cheering crowd of white citizens in and around Charlottesville, Virginia, gathered to dedicate the city’s newest statue: a 24-foot-tall equestrian monument of revolutionary war general George Rogers Clark (1752-1818), depicted as he charged into an unarmed crowd of Native men, women, and children. Since the earliest days of the US republic, when crowds tore down a statue of George III on July 6, 1776, in lower Manhattan, to the removal, renaming, and defending of Confederate monuments in our own time, citizens and leaders have debated the meaning of monuments in public life. These debates have often turned upon ideas of race, citizenship, and history, and they have generally fallen into two camps: those who see statues as history that can't be erased, and those who see statues as symbols designed to project a specific vision of the past (and, therefore, a topic that might do well to take a backseat to more pressing issues like human rights legislation, food insecurity, and affordable housing) (Savage 1997, Thompson 2021, Cox and Domby, eds., 2023, Hooker 2024). Despite years of research by historians and art historians, public debates about monuments have not changed much in the past 30 years. For their parts, HST scholars who have studied novel forms of copper metallurgy and the expansion of industrial mining in the 1910s-1920s have not tended to connect these new technologies and mechanized modes of extraction to changes in statuary. As an effort to reframe public conversations about statues, this talk borrows a lifecycle approach from STS (Geiser 2015, Mah 2023), to show how tracing metals and stones in public art back to their cultural and geographic origins offers a new framework and vocabulary for policy debates. Rather than seeing statues only as part of local landscapes, we begin to see them as products and processes of global chains of extraction, metallurgical processing, and industrial capitalism. This talk comes from chapter two of a book project that I am co-authoring with Teresa Pollak (Monacan), Beverly Payne (Occaneechi-Saponi), and Shaleigh Howells (settler, former cultural resources officer of the Pamunkey Nation), about our committee's work to remove the George Rogers Clark statue from the campus of the University of Virginia in 2021.
Bio:
Allison Bigelow is an associate professor in the Department of Romance Languages at the University of Notre Dame, where she teaches classes on the history of science and technology in Latin America, public monuments and historical memory, and community-engaged research methods. She is the author of 30-ish articles and chapters on those topics, as well as Mining Language: Racial Thinking, Indigenous Knowledge, and the Early Modern Iberian World (Omohundro Institute of Early American History and Culture/UNC Press, 2020), which received awards from HSS (Pauly Prize for First Book on the Americas), AHA (Rawley Prize for Atlantic History), MLA (First Book) and CLAH (Cline Prize for Latin American Ethnohistory, honorable mention). Her current book project, co-authored with Tribal consultants, traces the lifecycle of the University of Virginia's monument to George Rogers Clark, which stood on the campus from 1921 to 2021.